Show full text10 pages
Page 1
View in PDF(opens in a new window)The Hidden
Pavements of
Michelangelo's
Laurentian
Library
Jay Kappraff
ver since publishing my book
Connections: the Geometric
Bridge between Art and Science |1], 1
have become used to playing the role
of a “mathematical tourist.” I am frequently contacted by researchers keen
on discussing some discovery that they
have made and seeking my advice as
to the mathematical aspect of their
mathematical tourist attractions suck
Blake Summers; Rolf Bagemihl, an
archivist living in Florence; David Krell,
a philosopher; Arielle Saiber, a graduate
student at Yale specializing in Renaissance history; and Saori Hisano, a graduate student at Illinois Institute of
Technology, the college where Nicholson teaches. From time to time we
have also sought the help of other stuwork. Sometimes the work appears to
dents of Nicholson's, Salvatore Camshed new light on ancient or modern
geometry; other times it seems to lead
nowhere.
It is in this context that Ben Nicholson telephoned me three years ago. He
had become privy to a set of facsimiles
of fifteen 8’6” X 8/6” pavement designs—
possibly created by Michelangelo—
that lay hidden beneath the floorboards
of the Laurentian Library in Florence
[2,3]. He was trying to decipher their
geometries in order to enable him and
an artist, Blake Summers, to reconstruct
poreale, a Florentine theologian, and
Ernest McClain, a musicologist.
Isaw on my first visit to the studio
of Blake Summers that he was recreating the pavement designs with the
aid of a giant aluminum bar which
served as a compass. Summers and
Nicholson were using intuitive geometry very much in the spirit of Boethius,
who translated the Elements of Euclid
into a language understandable to the
them at full scale. This project definitely
Does your hometown have any
+
piqued my interest. One thing led to another, and I soon found myself a part of
Nicholson’s team of researchers devoted to the study of the pavements—
guilds of masons during Middle Ages.
In the process of analyzing the pavements we feel that we have discovered
a taxonomy of ancient geometry that
commingles all of the geometric systems handed down from antiquity into
an integrated whole. We have identias statues, plaques, graves, the café
where the famous conjecture was made,
the desk where the famous initials
are scratched, birthplaces, houses, or
memorials? Have you encountered
a mathematical sight on your travels?
If so, we invite you to submit to this
column a picture, a description of its
mathematical significance, and either
a map or directions so that others
may follow in your tracks.
Please send all submissions to
Mathematical Tourist Editor,
WIET
Dirk Huylebrouck, Aartshertogstraat 42,
Figure 1. Entrance stairway at the Laurentian Library. (Figs. 1-7 are from Firenze Biblioteca
8400 Oostende, Belgium
Medicea Laurenziana, salone de Michelangelo. By permission of the Minister of Culture.
e-mail: dirk.huylebrouck@ping.be
Further reproductions are strictly forbidden.)
THE MATHEMATICA. INTELLIGENCER © 1999 S2RINGER-VERLAG NEW YORK
Copyright ©2001. All Rights Reserved.
Page 2
View in PDF(opens in a new window)RAP TERITES
The Hidden
Pavements of
Michelangelos
Laurentian
Library
Jay Kappraff
Does your hometown have any
mathematical tourist attractions such
Dirk Huylebrouck,
Editor
ver since publishing my book
Blake
Connections:
archivist living in Florence; David Krell,
the
Geometric
Summers;
Rolf Bagemihl,
an
Bridge between Art and Science [1], I
a philosopher; Arielle Saiber, a graduate
have become used to playing the role
student at Yale specializing in Renaisof a “mathematical tourist.” I am fresance history; and Saori Hisano, a gradquently contacted by researchers keen
uate
on discussing some discovery that they
Technology, the college where Nicholstudent
at
Illinois
Institute
of
have made and seeking my advice as
son teaches. From time to time we
to the mathematical aspect of their
have also sought the help of other stuwork. Sometimes the work appears to
dents of Nicholson’s, Salvatore Camshed new light on ancient or modern
poreale, a Florentine theologian, and
geometry; other times it seems to lead
Ernest McClain, a musicologist.
nowhere.
It is in this context that Ben Nichol-
I saw on my first visit to the studio
of Blake Summers that he was recreson telephoned me three years ago. He
ating the pavement designs with the
had become privy to a set of facsimiles
aid of a giant aluminum bar which
of fifteen 8'6” x 8'6" pavement designs—
served as a compass. Summers and
possibly created by Michelangelo—
Nicholson were using intuitive geomethat lay hidden beneath the floorboards
try very much in the spirit of Boethius,
of the Laurentian Library in Florence
who translated the Elements of Euclid
[2,3]. He was trying to decipher their
into a language understandable to the
geometries in order to enable him and
guilds of masons during Middle Ages.
an artist, Blake Summers, to reconstruct
In the process of analyzing the pavethem at full scale. This project definitely
ments we feel that we have discovered
piqued my interest. One thing led to ana taxonomy of ancient geometry that
other, and I soon found myself a part of
commingles all of the geometric sys-
Nicholson’s team of researchers detems handed down from antiquity into
voted to the study of the pavements—
an integrated whole. We have identias statues, plaques, graves, the café
where the famous conjecture was made,
the desk where the famous initials
are scraiched, birthplaces, houses, or
memorials? Have you encountered
a mathematical sight on your travels?
If so, we invite you to submit to this
column a picture, a description of tis
mathematical significance, and either
a map or directions so that others
may follow in your tracks,
Please send all submissions to
Mathematica! Tourist Editor,
Dirk Huylebrouck, Aartshertogstraat 42,
8400 Oostende, Belgium
Medicea Laurenziana, salone de Michelangelo. By permission of the Minister of Culture.
e-mail: dirk.huylebrouck@ping.be
Further reproductions are strictly forbidden.)
Page 3
View in PDF(opens in a new window)upon
usual pavements. Further details of the
ries of fifteen panels, of different dewhich the pavements appear to be
history and significance of the pavesigns, each about 8'6” x 8'6”. The fifbased: (1) the Vesica Pisces [1,2]; (2)
ments can be found in Nicholson’s CDteen panels along one aisle mirror the
the law of repetition of ratios popular-
ROM, Thinking the Unthinkable House
ones on the other aisle, but differ in
ized by the 20th-century designer Jay
[10].
subtle ways. When juxtaposed, the 15
fied
six
principal
geometries
Hambridge under the name dynamic
Overall, the pavement consists of
symmetry [4,5]; (3) the eight-pointed
two side aisles and a figurative center
pairs of panels appear to tell a story
about the essentials of geometry and
Brunes star discovered by Tons Brunes,
aisle (Fig. 2). Desks situated on a raised
number. In 1928 the pavements were
the late Danish engineer [6,7,8]; (4) aset
of constructions based on V2 and rewooden dais have been placed over the
photographed for the first time when
pavements. On the side of each desk
the desks were removed temporarily
ferred to by Brunes as the sacred cut
are listed the books that were to be
whilst structural repairs were made to
[2,5,9]; (5) the ad-quadratum squarestored in it. Beneath the desks are a sethe subflooring (Fig. 3).
within-a square; and (6) the golden
mean [1,5].
Let me
summarize what I have
learned about this remarkable set of designs and briefly describe the structure
of two of them. The Laurentian Library,
which was designed by Michelangelo, is
situated on the second floor of the San
Lorenzo church complex in the heart of
Florence. Work on the library was begun in 1523 by Pope Clement VII, alias
Guilio Medici, the nephew of Lorenzo
di Medici, as a monument to his uncle;
it was opened to the public 48 years
later by his distant cousin, Grand Duke
Cosimo I.
The Library was meant to be ahome
for the books from antiquity that survived to the Renaissance. The modest
Setting of the Library leaves one utterly
unprepared for what one encounters
upon entering. First one is confronted
with a massive staircase (Fig. 1) calculated to provoke a numerological
trance: There are two steps to get into
the building, then series of 3 steps, 7
steps, and 5 steps, with 9 steps to the
left and right. After mounting the staircase one enters the Reading Room
(Fig. 2). Here the seeming regularity
and normalcy hides a frenzy of paradox and ambiguity. Just look at the
walls. There is no predominant structure. The wall consists of seven planes,
completely disorienting the viewer.
In 1774 a portentous accident occurred in the Reading Room of the
Laurentian Library. The shelf of desk
74, overladen with books, gave way
and broke. In the course of its ‘repair,
workmen found a red and white terracotta pavement which had lain hidden
for nearly 200 years beneath the floorboards. The librarian had trapdoors, still
operable today, built into the floor, so
future generations could view these un-
Figures 2 and 3. The Laurentian Library Reading Room—with and without desks.
Page 4
View in PDF(opens in a new window)Figure 4. a) The Index Panel 1; and b) the Cross Panel 15. (Figs. 4-7 are details of the pavements.)
The spatial conundrums, paradoxes,
the books make a counterpart to those
lated to an ancient musical scale based
and errancies of the building fabric reto the East and follow the epistemologon the first 10 numbers [11).
appear in the geometry of the paveical form devised by Aristotle. Across
Let's analyze two of the pavements.
ments.
from the poets are the texts related to
Panel 14 is referred to by Nicholson as
We think that the apparent
raggedness of the panels can be explithe trivium (grammar, rhetoric, and orthe Timaeus panel. It is composed of
cated as accurate and premeditated inatory), then on to logic, medicine, hisfour diamonds set within circles that are
terpretation of antique geometry in
tory, ethics, and metaphysics. Aristotle’s
cut with segments of circles, and the
terms of the philosophical concerns of
books were not bound in a single comwhole design is framed with a white borthe 1500s. Michelangelo was working
pendium as we might find them in a
der. In Fig. 5, this panel is shown juxtawith themes well understood at the
bookstore today, but were found in six
posed with a reproduction by Fabbrini,
time, a “secret art of geometry” which
different locations in the library, acfrom the circle of Michelangelo,
could be read in the pavement by the
cording to the part of his epistemology
Michelangelo’s system of proportions.
knowledgeable,
that they addressed. To traverse the
Michelangelo felt that the system of
length of the Reading Room could be
proportions developed at the time by
but which
is much
more inscrutable today.
The books in the Library were orof
thought of as a journey through the full
Diirer was inadequate to describe the
ganized with the sacred books to the
extent of the
wisdom and
supple human body, and that his own
East and the profane to the West, a
knowledge.
of
Monsignior Comporeale feels that
joints within the body. You will notice
throwback
to
the
ancient
“tree
world’s
system
better
allowed
for
flexible
knowledge”. On the East side, tucked
movement from Panel 1 (see Fig. 4a)
that Michelangelo provides a scale on
behind the projecting entrance door, is
near the door to Panel 15 (see Fig. 4b)
the right subdivided first into 2 parts,
a single desk whose books include the
on the other side of the Room may
then 4 and 8 parts, with each unit fur-
Koran,
and
have represented the Christian’s journey
ther subdivided into 3 parts for a total
books of magic. These subjects escape
from baptism to enlightenment. Panel 1
of 24 equal parts. This is reminiscent
the tidy categories used to order the
consists of octagons and crosses symof the lambda figure
Laurentian collection, and they were
bolic of baptism, while Panel 15, adjaplaced out of sight. The sequence hits
cent to the Pentateuch, also contains
its stride with 13 desks containing the
crosses
Kaballah,
Machiavelli,
and
10
concentric
sets
1
2
of
4
3
6
9
works of Italian, Latin, and Greek posquares surrounding a central square.
ets, and continues on through books
That the Hebrew Pentateuch is placed
devoted to the quadrivium (music, ashere may be deliberate metaphor for the
found in Plato’s Timaeus and referred
tronomy, geometry,
and arithmetic),
10-ness that pervades it: the 10 Comto there as the World Soul. This was
leading to 27 desks loaded with Latin
mandments, 10 generations to Abraham,
one of the neo-Platonic ideas brought
and Greek books of theology, ending
and 10 more to the Flood. Also Ernest
to the Renaissance by Ficino’s acad-
8
12
18
27
with books devoted to the Pentateuch.
McClain has found that much of the nuemy. It forms the basis of the musical
On the West side of the Reading Room,
merology of the Hebrew Bible can be resystem studied by Pythagoras and writ-
Page 5
View in PDF(opens in a new window)IRRATIONAL,
3
e.
».
|
e
4
‘toe
k"e
è
e
€
a
=
4
a
wD
a
Y
y
S
4
24 |
4
73
d
N
A
x
3
ES
ES
«|
Ss
=
Figure 5. The geometric construction of the Timaeus Panel 14.
ten about by Nichomachus [12,13,14],
The 27 units of Michelangelo’s sysand it was used by Alberti as the basis
tem of proportions can be found in
is subdivided into
However, itis surely deliberate that the
27 equal parts.
of his system of architectural propor-
Panel 14. The space from bottom
to top
seemingly similar space from left to
tions [5,9]. So we expect the number
27 in Michelangelo’s system rather
than 24. Sure enough, the head of the
model projects higher, the foot projects beneath the floor plane, and an
extra unit is intercalated at the hip.
Now we have the 27 units of the World
Soul.
Figure 6. The Medici Impressa.
Figure 7. The Cosimo Panel 2.
Page 6
View in PDF(opens in a new window)right has an extra, incommensurate inpanel. For that step, the smail differterval. The four circles of the figure
6. In the final step eight varieties of elence between the diagonal of the
lipses are created to fill the diamond
echo the coat of arms of Cosimo di
12 X 13 rectangle and the 13 X 13
shapes. Nicholson’s and Summer’s
Medici, which is also emblazoned on
square is exploited. Circles with this
reconstruction of panel 2 is shown
small difference as radii are drawn
in Fig. 9.
the pavements of the central aisle (Fig.
6). Each of the 27 units is exactly 3 solwhere the 24 circles intersect the
dis in width resulting in an 81-square
pitch circle to yield 48 new points
grid for the entire design. The panel
on the pitch circle (Fig. 8d).
What appeared as a kind of errancy
in the deviation of the rectangle from
across from this on the other side of the
. Forty-eight additional circles with
a square exploded into the entire delibrary appears to be based on an 80-
radius equal to the pitch circle are
sign. Furthermore, in the steps leading
square grid. Is it coincidental that the
now drawn. These demarcate the
to its creation, a series of 3, 6, 12, 24,
ratio 80:81, known in musical parlance
white bands of the Medici panel (Fig.
48, and 96 circles are created. This is
as the syntonic comma, is exactly the
8e).
the series that led to the Titius-Bode
ratio by which the tones of the ancient
scale, attributed to the followers of
Pythagoras based onthe primes 2 and
3, differs from the Just scale, based on
primes 2, 3, and 5? Such conundrums
are found over and over in the structure
of the pavements.
Panel 2, the Medici panel (Fig. 7), is
a rosette form typical of many such antique rosette forms that appeared at the
time in Florence. The pavement is a rectangle of dimension 12 X 13. Nicholson
feels that these numbers are significant
as the number of months in the solar
and lunar calendars. The small difference between a square and a rectangle
is crucial to its construction.
1. In the first step in the construction,
the rectangle is extended to a 13 X
13 square concentric with a 12 X 12
square, and the horizontal and vertical axes are placed in the squares.
An equilateral triangle is drawn to a
side of the 12 X 12 square. The distance from the center of the square
to the vertex of the triangle is the
radius of a standard circle of the
construction called the pitch circle
(Fig. 8a). Beginning where the pitch
circle cuts the horizontal axis, six
circles of radius equal to the pitch
circle are drawn (Fig. 8b).
2. Next
six
additional
circles
are
drawn beginning where the pitch
circle cuts the vertical axis.
3. Twelve additional circles are drawn
by repeating steps 2 and 3 for the
pair of perpendicular diagonals of
gle in a square establishes the pitch circle;
the squares resulting in a 24-rosette
b) a rosette of six circles; c} a rosette of 24
pattern (Fig. 8c).
4. Twenty-four additional circles are
28
circles; d) the mismatch of the diagonals of
the 12 x 12 square and the 12 x 13 rectangle
drawn half-way between the circles
generates 48 additional circles; e) ninety-six
of the rosette. These will be widened
circles create a set of spiral bands in which
into the white bands appearing in the
eight classes of ellipses are placed.
Page 7
View in PDF(opens in a new window)Acknowledgments
Dynamic Symmetry. Originally published
As you can see, this project has mateby
rialized for me into the ultimate of
New York: Dover)
mathematical
tours.
I
wish
to
acknowledge the fruitful collaboration
that I have undertaken with my colleagues,
Ben
Nicholson
and
Saori
Dynamarhythmic Design
(1932)
(rpt.
. Brunes, T. The Secrets of Ancient Geometry
and its Use. Copenhagen: Rhodos (1967).
. Kappraff,
J.
Geometry.”
“A
In
Secret
Geometry
of
at
Ancient
Work:
A
Hisano, that has made this work a great
Collection of Papers in Applied Geometry
pleasure.
edited by K. Gorini. Math. Assoc. of Amer.
Notes (In press).
. Kappraff,
REFERENCES
1. Kappraff, J. Connections: The Geometric
Bridge between Art and Science.
New
J.
Mathematics
Beyond
Measure: A Guided Tour through Nature,
Myth,
and Number.
New York:
Plenum
Press (In press).
York: McGraw-Hill Books. (1991).
2. Nicholson, B., Kappraff, J., and Hisano, S.
. Kappraff, J. “Musical Proportions at the
“A Taxonomy of Ancient Geometry Based
Basis of Systems of Architectural Proporon the Hidden Pavements of Michelantion both Ancient and Modern.” In Nexus:
gelo’s
Architecture and Mathematics edited by
Laurentian
Library.”
In
Art
and
law that predicted the positions of the
Science: The Proceedings of the Second
K. Williams. Fuccechio: Edizioni dell’Erba
planets up until Saturn. Again, is this
Conference on Art and Science edited by
(1996).
coincidence or prescience? The pave-
J. Barrallo, San Sebastian, Spain: Univ. of
10. Nicholson,
B.
“Architecture,
ment mirroring Panel 2 is placed in an
the Basque Country Press (1998), and in
Geometry.”
In
CD-Rom: ' Thinking the
11 X 12
square perhaps symbolizing
Bridges: Mathematical Connections in Art,
Unthinkable House. Renaissance Society
the 12 disciples and the 11 disciples
Music and Science: Conference Proceedat the University of Chicago (1997).
once Judas was excluded.
ings edited by R. Sarhangi, Arkansas City,
The question begging to be asked is
Books +
11. McClain, E. “The Star of David as Jewish
Harmonical Metaphor.” International Journ.
KS: Gilliland Publ. (1998).
of Musicology. Vol. 6, pp. 24-49. (1997).
why 30 magnificent pavements would
3. Nicholson, B., Kappraff, J., and Hisano, S.
be constructed and then covered up.
“The Hidden Pavements of the Laurentian
12. McClain, E. Private communication.
Perhaps some cryptic symbols were
Library.”
13. McClain, E. The Pythagorean Plato. York
concealed within the pavements in the
Mathematics
manner of Umberto Eco’s Name of the
In
Nexus
Il: Architecture and
edited
by
K.
Willams.
Fuccechio, Italy: Edizioni dell’Erba (1998).
Rose and then hidden to prevent their
4. Hambridge, J. The Elements of Dynamic
revelation. Nicholson has a more mun-
Symmetry. Originally published by Brentdane hypothesis. When the library was
ano’s (1929) (rot. By New York: Dover).
conceived there were approximately
5. Edwards, E.B. Pattern and Design with
Beach, ME: Nicolas-Hays (1978).
14. McClain,
E.
“Temple
Tuning
Systems.”
International Journ. of Musicology, 3 (1994).
New Jersey Institute of Technology
Newark, NJ 07102
USA
1000 books in existence. When it was
completed, the Library contained over
3000. The Library had to be reconfigured to accommodate the new books.
In the original plan for the Library, a
Revealing a Lost Body of Knowledge
triangular room was supposed to have
been constructed to house the rarest
In the summer of 1998, Ben Nicholson, Saori Hisano, and the author preof the books. However, this room was
sented their research at two major conferences: The Second International
never built.
Conference on Art and Mathematics directed by Vera Martha Winitzky de
Unfortunately we do not know who
created the pavements. The books listing the financial transactions in connection with them would most likely have
listed the designer, but they have been
lost.
However,
surely
Michelangelo
would at least have had a major say concerning such a crucial component of his
Spinadel and Maria Emiliana Uranga Otaegui in San Sebastian, Spain; and
Nexus II directed by Kim Williams in Mantua, Italy. I then made a presentation at the Bridges Conference directed by Reza Sarhangi at Southwestern
College in Winfield, Kansas. We also had a meeting in Florence with the
Director and Chief Librarian of the Laurentian Library. As a result of this
meeting, the Library agreed to sponsor an exhibition of the pavement research, which might prompt the community to think about exposing this lost
body of knowledge to the open air.
library.
Page 8
View in PDF(opens in a new window)More or Less
Mathematics
Wanted in
Engineering?
Two images, one of the medieval
plied numeracy. We will return to this
cellarium at Fountains Abbey, England,
question later.
At school I liked and was good at
and another of a tiled forecourt in
mathematics. Once the prettiest girl in
Vernon, France, inspired two engineers
the class allowed me to kiss her in exto different conclusions. The first
change for letting her copy my maths
author considers that the importance of
homework. That is the only time in my
life, and I am a sexagenarian, that I’ve
abstract mathematics is somewhat
ever found a use for mathematics. More
overrated, and he even makes an
seriously, it has been my experience that
appeal to the scientific community to
very few engineers use mathematics in
support his view. The second author
practice. They have of course to be nucalls for another kind of intervention:
merate. The insistence on mathematics
for all engineers has been a damaging
he asks for some mathematical
deterrent to some highly capable, imagassistance by proposing an unsolved
inative, and creative people. Engineerproblem to readers. Perhaps engineers
ing is after all about making things work.
The empirical approach, trial and error,
and mathematicians will have
the ability to experiment quickly is of
reactions, outraged or otherwise, to
much more importance. Most problems
cannot be solved by mathematics anycontribute to The Intelligencer’s
way, or they have to be reduced to too
letters.—D.H.
simple a model to be useful.
I expressed this view in a rather
light-hearted manner in an article pub-
A. Less Mathematics and
lished internally within my university.
More Numeracy Wanted in
To my surprise, many colleagues said
Engineering
that what I had said needed saying
Edward Reed
again
and again.
The professor of
To give academic respectability to a trivmathematics got the vapours, refused
ial piece of engineering research, it is
to speak to me, and shortly afterwards
standard practice to add some mathetook early retirement. I also likened
matics to make it appear more signifimathematics
in
engineering
to
the
cant than it is. Mathematics is the silicon
wowing of ladies: as there is supposed
implants of academia. This is not to be
to be a lot of it about and since most
confused with numeracy. Numeracy is
men find little of it coming their way
highly relevant for engineers and unfortunately is often lacking (see Figure 1).
Most readers will have looked at the
drawing,
read the
caption
and
answered the question before even reading the first paragraph. I understand
this is a question in Trivial Pursuit, although I cannot confirm it. The answer
universally accepted is the Great Wall
of China. The real question is, is this
true? I ask students, colleagues, and
friends this question. Some look it up in
books, like Hutchinson’s New Century
Encyclopaedia (Helicon Publishing Ltd.,
1995), or the Readers’ Digest Book of
Facts. They choose between the supporters of the common positive answer, as proposed in the first reference, or the opponents, as in the latter.
30
Few give areasoned answer. What Iam
Figure 1. What is the only man-made object
really after is some common sense, apthat can be seen on Earth from the Moon?
Page 9
View in PDF(opens in a new window)course numerate: they needed to calculate such matters as the number of
eggs required for the mortar (see Figure
2). Back to the Great Wall problem.
Here is one solution. Put your thumb in
front of you and hold it up to the Moon.
The Moon appears as a small disc about
one-sixth the size of your thumbnail. By
estimation it can be said that an object
as far away and as big as the Moon—
which is about 3000 km across—appears about 3 mm across to the eye. If
we estimate that the wall is 5m across,
we can calculate by proportion what
thickness it would appear to somebody
on the Moon. The answer is that it is
much too small for even the most powerful of telescopes, let alone the naked
eye. An often expressed view that the
wall can be seen because itis over 2000
Figure 2. The medieval cellarium at Fountains Abbey, England (photograph reproduced by
kind permission of Yorkshire Post Newspapers).
km long is patently daft. It is hoped that
the wall example has demonstrated
what is meant by numeracy.
they believe somebody else must be
skills. Bridges are built as something fit
doing awfully well.
for the purpose at the most economi-
After learning my views on mathecal price, and they have been since time
matics, many of my critics tell me that
immemorial. The medieval builder had
they would not like to pass over a
only wood and stone, but he could conbridge that I had designed. Neither
struct stone arches and knew that if a
My area is mechatronics.
shape, known to us as a catenary, could
However, bridge-building will serve as
be drawn so as to go through every
would
I:
an example. No bridge was ever built
stone, then his arch would stand up.
by mathematics. They are designed and
The great medieval bridges and cathebuilt by teams of engineers requiring a
drals of Europe were built without
vast range of skills; the more grandiose
mathematicians, but the builders had to
the bridge, the bigger the range of
be imaginative, creative, skilled, and of
>x
Wa x
EA
ANSa
_pMontvi| tiers NS rñteabones
EX
‘seWandnlien
N E mx
N
en- „=
Gougnay-en
Pi.
>?
==
Vascoeuile
rouyille
Q
i
”
L
NN
Tyons-a-Forèt .
rua
o =
Br
zauville
> Derieüiy-s-Andeile
N
| _FPörtreveaue
RN
ì
Monto
fort’
le Becpet 19
Brionne
Lisieux
Gisors
gt-/
ae
>”
DIA
Les Andelys: 3
N
=>;
,
Nest: Clair",
NN y 7
cal “Magny:-en-Vex
Ordece
4
)
=
(
q
eVimoutiers
\
=
7
>
08.7
EN
N
2 Sia Neuve
=
Figure 3. Map of France, locating Vernon.
*Conches- en-
È
5
Mantesy <=
uche
i
=
=
=~
Figure 4. The tiled forecourt in Vernon—is
there a pattern?
Page 10
View in PDF(opens in a new window)As a teacher of engineering, I have
B. More Mathematics Required
up of five different blocks: 3 X 2, yelproblems with students and their numerical skills even if their mathematto Explain an Ingenious Tiling
low; and 2 x 2 and 2 x 1 in both black
Pattern in Vernon, France
and white, but their arrangement apics is good. I recently did an overseas
R.J. Holroyd
pears to be neither regular nor irreguanother's
While on holiday in France I visited
the pattern might be an example of aslar.
exchange with another teacher, which
involved + us
taking
one
A mathematician suggested that
classes. I found his students similarly
Vernon, a small town that stands on the
ymptotic periodicity and referred to
poor at numerical work, so maybe this
Seine about midway between Paris and
me to some algebra textbooks, but so
is
Numeracy
the sea. (See figure 3.) About a mile upfar as I could see these did not shed
might be boring and mathematics exstream is the small village of Giverny,
any light on the problem. Out of my
citing: I confess to having found this so
with the house and gardens where
depth
at school. However it is numerical
Monet spent the last half of his life.
mathematics, apparently so different
a
universal
problem.
about
these
mathematician’s
skills that are most lacking in engi-
While walking around the town, I came
from the usual engineering computaneering students. Perhaps mathematiacross a recently built arts centre (the
tions, I would welcome any enlightencians should address themselves to
Espace
ment about this fascinating pattern—
this problem.
with an intriguingly tiled forecourt. I
Culturel
Philippe
Auguste)
or lack of pattern.
was told that the workmen had a plan
Leeds Metropolitan University
for laying the blocks, but no one could
104 Arbury Road
Leeds LS1 3HE
tell me how the plan was produced.
Cambridge CB4 2JF
United Kingdom
The pattern, shown in figure 4, is made
United Kingdom
EXPAND YOUR MATHEMATICAL
BOUNDARIES!
Mathematics Without Borders
A History of the International Mathematical Union
S
As told by Professor Olli Lehto, the history of the Intemational Mathematical Union (IMU) is surprisingly compelling
The twentieth century has been fraught with tremendous international conflict, but there has also been a great deal of
Congresses throughout the world, effectively bridging cultural and political gaps by uniting scientists through their genuine
love and appreciation for mathematics.
For anyone strictly interested in the mathematical and organizational details of the IMU Congresses, this book will serve
as an excellent resource. However, Mathematics Without Borders also takes time to focus on the individuals, many of
them leading mathematicians of the twentieth century, and their stories-told against the backdrop of world events.
Contents: Prologue to the History of the IMU e The Old IMU (1920-1932) e Mathematical Cooperation Without the IMU (1933-1939) e Foundation
of the New IMU (1945-1951) e The IMU Takes Shape (1952-1954) e Expansion of the IMU (1955-1958) e The IMU and Intemational Congresses
(1958-1962) e Consolidation of the IMU (1963-1970) e North-South and East-West Connections (1971-1978) + Politics Interferes with the IMU
(1979-1986) e The IMU and Related Organizations « The IMU in a Changing World (1986-1990)
1998/368 PP., 53 FIGS./HARDCOVER/$35.00/ISBN 0-387-98358-9
Order Today! Call: 1-800-SPRINGER + Fax: (201)-348-4505 + Visit: {http://www.springer-ny.com}
5/98
Promotion #H232