Mostrar texto completo14 páginas
Página 1
Ver en el PDF(se abre en una ventana nueva)No hay texto en esta página.
Página 2
Ver en el PDF(se abre en una ventana nueva)Introduction
A modern scientist will tell you that the language of the universe can be found in
mathematics. Every process in nature can be compiled into formulae and understood
through numbers. If Physics shows the laws of cosmos, Chemistry the composition of
cosmic creations, and Biology the rules that these creations follow, then they all can
be assimilated under the umbrella that is Mathematics. Mankind's progress is written
in the development of mathematical studies. The growth of our civilization lies in the
hands of mathematics, and those who water that plant of numericals with newer
approaches everyday.
In analysing the universe and our world with this modern scientific outlook, we tend
to forget to look back. Even when we do, we don't ponder far enough. Our
understanding of science comes from the rudimentary sense of modern development.
Nothing beyond a few centuries interests us when we ask, "What has mankind
achieved as a species that can read and experiment?" This partial look back creates a
void in our understanding of human history: we see ourselves start as savage beings
drawing animals on cave walls, then building cities in the name of invisible gods, to
become a species that rapidly furthered its knowledge through hypotheses and
research. Human history is not such a simplistic territory: the stage for science was set
at the same time when cities built temples larger than themselves in the name of
invisible gods.
Here, I come back to mathematics. And with the numbers I bring the cult that changed
mathematics as we know: Pythagoreanism.
Pythagoras is quite a familiar name. The theorem in his name is taught to students
across the world in schools. When we calculate how long the hypotenuse of a right
angle triangle would be, we do not exactly think of a cult, or music and poetry. And
when we discuss cults, mathematical or scientific progress isn't the first idea that
occurs. Pythagoreans smother all those notions. Instead, they offer a view of the
universe that is truly well ahead of their time, and has since been forgotten.
Academia is quick to divide mathematics, music, poetry and art into their own
domains, albeit admitting there is some connection between them. But it would be
grave injustice to read a poem or study a song without giving thought to the math
behind it. Pythagoreans accepted this relationship, and they rightly bestowed the
prowess of these elements on one god: Apollo.
Página 3
Ver en el PDF(se abre en una ventana nueva)No hay texto en esta página.
Página 4
Ver en el PDF(se abre en una ventana nueva)theorem until Pythagoras has much to do with the implications of irrational numbers,
more on which has been discussed later. Through contacts with India via Arab,
Pythagoras and his followers became masters of mathematics. They observed nature
to draw conclusions. They conducted experiments to understand the why's of nature,
instead of merely seeing them as vague messages from the divine. They proposed that
the sun was a ball of fire, earth a sphere, and the stars other balls of fire, but too
distant to make their heat feel like the sun. The sun's precise movement across the sky
and the routine of its rise and fall throughout the year created a sense of stability. And
this stability, according to Pythagoreans, comes from the fact that mathematics itself is
a stable subject, and therefore it must be the language of the universe.
According to Pythagoreans, the world is composed of opposites: heat/cold, dry/wet,
and so on. The key to understanding these opposites lies in mathematics. Their motto
was "All is number" or "God is number". For instance, to them the even numbers
represented the infinite, as when they are halved again and again, the final result is
always 1. The even numbers were male. The odd numbers represented the finite,
because they were not divisible as even numbers, and female. The number 5 signified
marriage, as the sum of 2 and 3. It has strong influence of the gender dynamics of the
time.
Thus, they derived that the universe had originated from Chaos (καος), a concept
which Ovid later propagates, and the earth and other heavenly bodies were arranged in
an order only when complex mathematical relations came to play. Instead of Gaia in
the myths, Chaos was followed by mathematical order. This order exhibits itself in
everything around us, because they all create one unit: The Universe. Pythagoreans
gave immense importance to the number 1. They saw 1 as the generator: the number
from which all other numbers arise.
The math of art
To better understand the mathematics of the universe, they attached the concept of
music and art to it. Music and poetry, which were often performed as musical poetry
in Classical Greece, had an identifiable pattern of beats and rhythm. They believed
that music has the same effect as medicine on the human body, a theory proven true in
some parts today. The Ancient Greeks saw poetry and music as abstract and divinely
inspired. Therefore the perfection in music through mathematics gave them a bridge
between the divine and the mundane. This principle became highly important, as it
was seen as a means to imitate and reach the gods themselves. The precision of
mathematics in nature was to be imitated in music and art so as to make them perfect,
and this principle plays into the excellent Greek sculptures that we see today. The
Página 5
Ver en el PDF(se abre en una ventana nueva)No hay texto en esta página.
Página 6
Ver en el PDF(se abre en una ventana nueva)This led Ancient Greeks to build monuments of precise mathematical order. Perhaps
the best example is the Parthenon in Athens: an example of the fine architectural
achievement of the Greeks. Each pillar of the Parthenon is designed using optical
refinement to look organic by thickening them at the base, while also ensuring they
were strong enough to hold the ceiling in place. The façade of the temple used the
Golden Ratio (1:1.618). The Caryatid is yet another fine example.
Página 7
Ver en el PDF(se abre en una ventana nueva)No hay texto en esta página.
Página 8
Ver en el PDF(se abre en una ventana nueva)(Below) A close-up of the pillars of Parthenon, Athens, built:447 and 432 BC. The
shape of the column shafts, and their slight tilt from the vertical, are said to correct
optical distortions so that the building appears to be perfectly regular. The columns
taper towards the top, but also swell slightly part of the way up, to avoid an
impression of narrowing at the centre.
Pythagoreans were the first to experiment with strings to create music. AC Grayling
writes,
"The mathematician Aristoxenos said that Pythagoras was the first to take the study of
arithmetic beyond the practical needs of commerce…the pitch of a musical note
depends on the length of a string whose vibrations produce the note, and that simple
numerical ratios explain the consonant intervals of the scale: 2:1 octave, 3:2 perfect
fifth, 4:3 perfect fourth, and so on. To understand this, think of two guitar strings of
equal length, tension and thickness. If they are both plucked together they sound the
same. If different lengths of each are plucked, they sometimes sound dissonant and
sometimes consonant. This latter observation underlies measurement of consonant
intervals – an interval being the distance between two notes, and a consonant interval
being one in which the two notes sound good together. Experiment will show that if
you have two lengths of string of equal length, tension and thickness, plucking one
while simultaneously plucking exactly half the length of the other will yield a
consonance – this is the octave."
Music and poetry both employ meter: the key to make them sound pleasant to the ears.
Astronomical developments of the Pythagoreans
This mathematics of music, they took to the planets, proposing the idea of harmonia
or harmony. For the world to exist there needs to be order, and harmony is the
mathematical display of this order. In fact, the idea of entropy heavily depends on the
existence of ordered law, and therefore both creation and destruction are calculable
ideas. According to them, planets are arranged in a concentric series of paths, and
every planet emits its own music based on its size, position and so on. Today, we
know this is true to some extent thanks to the various space probes we have sent out to
outer space: "In 2022, people on Earth were able to hear the planetary sounds of Mars
thanks to two microphones installed on board NASA's Perseverance rover…The
planetary sounds we hear, are wavelike vibrations of air molecules occurring within
the range of frequencies to which our ears are sensitive, according to the BBC …it's
possible to process any other kind of wave or oscillation electronically, scaling it to
audible frequencies and then converting it into a sound wave…The process of turning
Página 9
Ver en el PDF(se abre en una ventana nueva)non-acoustic data into audible sounds — called sonification — can have benefits for
astronomers involved in analysing the data, according to Scientific American."
Saturn's radio emissions, which have changes in frequency (127Kb Wave Sound).1
Pythagoreans suggested that that the moon has no light of its own, but merely reflects
the light of the sun. They held the opinion that beyond the planetary system we know,
there are other planetary systems as well, with their own suns. They also proposed the
revolutionary idea of reincarnation: Metempsychosis. This was possibly an influence
of Indo-Greek exchange of ideas as well, but for Europe this was a first. Pythagoras
deeply supported the idea that good deeds can help one transcend the cycle of rebirths
to reach the divine, something the Vedas and Buddhist philosophies also support.
The intersection of the divine and the mundane
The work of the Pythagoreans in understanding the world through mathematics
closely linked the belief system around Apollo. I had previously mentioned that
Apollo is the god of prophecies in the Greek pantheon: he alone has the power to
foresee events in the future that are bound to happen. Even in this, mathematics plays
a vital role. Astronomers today can make complex calculations to understand the age
of the universe, how long the sun will last, and predict cosmic events at a time scale
that we can hardly comprehend. For instance, by studying the weather and climate of a
place in the past, scientists can build a mathematical model that would allow them to
predict the weather in the upcoming days. Such formulae are also used to predict how
the sun will age and when it becomes a Red Star, how far it will expand. Pythagoreans
recognised the possibility of building such numerical models, although they
themselves could not make astronomical predictions with the accuracy we have now.
Thus, it would not be a mistake to say that mathematics is the key to seeing the future,
Image from NASA
Página 10
Ver en el PDF(se abre en una ventana nueva)No hay texto en esta página.
Página 11
Ver en el PDF(se abre en una ventana nueva)In this, Pythagoreans recognised the mathematics of war. From the use of weaponry to
formation of armies, called strategia, the use of mathematics can help a warrior win
even with limited resources. The accuracy of an arrow depends on the calculations
that go into shooting it, and Apollo is a master of both. Modern weapons use
mathematical equations to shoot missiles, which again depend on satellites built
through math. Even though guns have replaced arrows, Apollo's influence on warfare
remains.
Apollo is also said to have shot arrows of plague towards the enemy, and use his skills
in medicine to heal his worshippers. Modern medicine is heavily dependent on
mathematical calculations, and this must have held true for the Pythagoreans as well.
They could observe the calculated precision required to concoct a medicine: how the
excess or lacking of an ingredient could change a medicine from potent to poisonous.
They could also have seen the relation between weather and disease. Thus a proper
calculation of weather could tell them if they would be plagued by disease or spared.
The plague would also depend on location, and Pythagoreans were heavily engaged in
calculating the earth's size and where various states were located on the surface of the
earth. The relation between music and health is also another proof of how well they
understood the importance of math in everyday life. Patients of dementia are often
told to listen to music to help their nerve cells, and the mathematical patterns of a song
help regulate the body's blood flow. Pythagoras is attributed to have first discovered
the link between music and wellness of mind.
According to scholars: "One day, (Pythagoras) was passing by a blacksmith, and
suddenly, he noticed the sound of a hammer and found it to be musical. He rushed
inside the shop and started beating hammers of different sizes on the table. He
observed that the tune played by the hammer was directly proportional to the size of
the hammer, hence he proved that music was mathematical."
The Pythagoras Theorem
a² + b² = c²
The Pythagoras theorem has multifaceted uses, which the Pythagoreans perfected. The
precision of Greek architecture has been mentioned before, so it is no surprise that the
Pythagoras theorem is used even today by architects and engineers. Here too we find
Apollo, who alongside Poseidon built the impregnable walls of Troy. The
Pythagoreans who grew up listening to the myth of Troy saw in those walls the
mathematical tricks of building strong structures, and Apollo as the builder only
reinforced their faith in the god as the greatest mathematician. As the myth goes,
Página 12
Ver en el PDF(se abre en una ventana nueva)Apollo also predicted that the wall will only fall on the third attempt, as would the city
of Troy. A prediction of this sort can be made by a modern engineer as well, thanks to
numerical equations. Plato is believed to have heavily derived from Pythagoras' study
of mathematical principles, and used it to derive logic and reasoning in his own works.
Geometry provided architects with the tools necessary for proper design and
construction (Leonardis, 2016). The temple construction was based on the use of such
ratios as 2:3 and 4:9. Moving from more minor parts to more significant amounts was
the fundamental strategy based on the essence of symmetry. This design led to the
construction of buildings characterized by such concepts as symmetry and harmony3
Pythagoreans did not remain confined to right angled triangles. They discovered that
the "sum of all angles of a triangle is equal to two right angles" and that "polygon with
n sides is equal to (2n-4) right angles and the sum of its exterior angles is equal to four
right angles….They were also able to compute the solution of equations like a(a-x)=
x² with the help of geometry."
IvyPanda. (2023, July 5). Mathematics in Ancient Greek Architecture.
Página 13
Ver en el PDF(se abre en una ventana nueva)They also pondered over the geometry of Tectactys: representing the number 10. It
closely tied to the representation of numbers via dots. The Tectactys is perfect in their
opinion because it represents the four Classical elements: fire, water, earth, and air.
As Grayling writes: "Pythagoreans thought that ten is the natural basis of counting,
and gave it a mystical significance. There is of course an infinity of ‘triangular
numbers’ – three is represented as the triangle of two dots with one dot above it; six is
represented as a triangle of dots arranged ‘3–2–1’; ten we have seen, fifteen is
‘5–4–3–2–1’, and so on."
4
Conclusion
It is rather easy to dismiss Pythagoreanism as a cult that coincidentally got things
right. They faced quite some barriers in their studies. For instance, they are attributed
with discovering irrational numbers, but the experience stumped them so much that
the one man who revealed this finding to the other members was punished by being
drowned to death. Some scholars believe that the irrational numbers caused
Mesopotamians to give up studying the Pythagoras theorem. The Pythagoreans used a
simple explanation: if the horizontal side is 1 inch (or 1 metre, yard, and so on), then
the diagonal would be the root of 2. But the root of 2 is not a whole number, and
neither is it the familiar fractional number. This shocked them, yet, they recorded the
discovery and today irrational numbers are as indispensable as rational numbers. And
we know that the rule applied to musical strings does not adhere to planetary
positions. But for us to reach these conclusions, as well as make impressive progress
Grayling; History of Philosophy
Página 14
Ver en el PDF(se abre en una ventana nueva)with the aid of math, the contributions of Pythagoreans must be admitted. Their
understanding of the universe can be simply assimilated in one figure: Apollo. And
when one sees the connections that thread together the god's powers, one can see the
dedication and precision of the people who worshipped him.
Mankind has often been set back in their progress by socio-political factors. But the
loss of Pythagoras' works and those written under him is a grave blow to our progress
that is worth acknowledging. A mathematician who undertakes the difficult task of
finding the meaning of the universe must start with Pythagoras and his school.
Because this is where our collective journey as a species to find reason against the
vast cosmic background began and took a prolific shape. It set the stage upon which
our society stands today.